Archive for March, 2019

A R Venkatachalapathy’s “Thamizhk kalakkalanjiyaththin kadhai”

March 6, 2019

This short and very readable biography of the Tamil encyclopaedia is very good. A review of the book by Perumal Murugan is in Kalachuvadu here.

I enjoyed the book and have no hesitations in recommending it to anybody who can read Tamil. However, at some points, I could not help but feel that A R Venkatachalapathy was a bit unfair. One example is the way Kalki is credited. Apparently Kalki suggested the chief editor’s name; but ARV attributes the credit to choosing Thooran as editor to Avinashilingam Chettiyar. Apparently, Kalki also suggested the Treasurer who swindled. But, in this case, ARV is silent about Avinashilingam Chettiyar’s ability in identifying the right person for the right job. There are similar comments about Ma Po Si and  S A P Annamalai which I thought were less than charitable. These are minor quibbles though.

As Perumal Murugan has suggested in his review, a more detailed book or an expanded edition will be very welcome and the current version is certainly a good placeholder till that happens.

Advertisements