The teaching triangle or pyramid?

Jay Parini, in his Art of teaching, says, that for instruction, all you need is a student, a teacher and some log to sit on. Generalizing the log, and calling it the tools, one sees that the teaching triangle has for its vertices the tools, the teacher and the student. All three are essential for teaching to happen. However, what ties together all these three vertices is the subject of discussion. Thus, it is more of a pyramid with the subject of discussion forming the fourth vertex.

So, what happens, if any of the vertices disentangle from any other? Obviously, the pyramid collapses. When I am teaching and/or preparing to teach, I continuously worry about my holding on to the vertices of students, subject and tools. While I have control (or, at least I tend to think that I have control) over the subject end and tools end, sometimes, I tend to lose the students — individually or, worse still, as a group. Of course, this might be due to the fact that I have not yet mastered the tools and the subject well enough to make students stick to the task of instruction and sharing. But, the feeling that in spite of your best efforts students get disentangled from the process for reasons outside of your purview and control does pop up occasionally; and, it is quite frustrating when I get such a feeling.

ArunN points to a piece in Chronicle which talks about the problem of students disentangling from the other vertices, the possible reasons and causes for this disentanglement (some of which do lie outside the college campus) and some hints as to what helps in preventing such disentanglement:

Arum and Roksa point out that students in math, science, humanities, and social sciences—rather than those in more directly career-oriented fields—tend to show the most growth in the areas measured by the Collegiate Learning Assessment, the primary tool used in their study. Also, students learn more from professors with high expectations who interact with them outside of the classroom. If you do more reading, writing, and thinking, you tend to get better at those things, particularly if you have a lot of support from your teachers.

The piece seems to be the first in a series; may be it is worth while to follow it up and think on some of the issues discussed!

Update: Another piece about teaching; I can see one difference though; unlike patients who do want to be cured of their current ailments, students might be happy with their current status, or, might want something else which is not part of the mandate!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: