Reviewing the reviews

It is always fun to read the review of reviews: the best example of such reviews is the series that Open Letters Monthly publishes for book reviews called Peer Review — take a look at this review of reviews of Guenter Grass, or, this one of Philip Roth for example.

In a similar fashion, but on an entirely different note, Arunn at Unruled Notebook (Hat tip to Gandham for the email alert) decides to have some fun interpreting, de-constructing and at times, just plain translating, the review of a music concert that appeared in the Hindu:

Though sporting a coquettish swing, there was dignity of Carnatic music.

Like commercial break between programs, this means ROFL break for my (Shri. SVK) review.

Through his competent singing (as agreed by me in the earlier sentences) Kasturi Rangan made me see the feminine swing (of hips?) of Mademoiselle Carnatic music. After enjoying it for a while, I realized it is wrong on my part to do so in public, so I shift the blame squarely on to Mademoiselle Carnatic music for sporting such an ungainly feminine swing that almost robbed her of dignity.

Long karvais, loops, gorgeous sancharas formed the raga edifice. His creativity was well matured by intensity of feeling with a skilful control of form.

All because of this good, creative singer Kasturi Rangan. Shame on him.

His training under a towering vidwan helped him enormously in the rendering of kirtanas.

Aha! He is very good because he trained under TNS.

His interpretation of ‘Sri Ranganayakam’ (Nayaki) and ‘Saragunapalimpa’ (Kedaragowla) clearly brought out the radiance of the composition. The spiritual excellence of the Nayaki kirtana was unfolded stressing its specific beauties. The shades of the raga in the song were precisely and compellingly revealed.

The Kedaragowla kirtana with its structural cohesiveness and chittaswaram was presented with passionate gracefulness. One significant feature noticeable was full-steam articulation both in ragas and kirtanas. But there was lack of clarity in the enunciation of sahityas.

Nayaki and Kedaragowla ragas and the follow up kirtanas were brilliantly done. Nayaki and Kedaragowla are difficult ragas to handle. Their important phrases present in the respective kirtanas were skillfully brought out. The singing was lively but the sahitya words were not sung with clarity.

If he desires to proclaim his individual identity he has to move away from the shadow of Seshagopalan.

Let me (Shri. SVK) close with the critic patented hypocritical cliche. Kasturi Rangan should move away from the “shadow” of Seshagopalan to prove himself to me.

Take a look!

Advertisements

Tags: ,

2 Responses to “Reviewing the reviews”

  1. Arunn Says:

    Guru

    Thanks for the link to the post.

    Arunn at Unruled Notebook (Hat tip to Gandham for the email alert) decides to have some fun

    This recent re-review is the fifth in this SVK series at the blog…

    Cheers,
    Arunn

  2. Guru Says:

    Dear Arunn

    Thanks for stopping by and the pointers. This is the first one I read, and, as you can see, I enjoyed it a lot too. I will go read the backlog at your blog!

    Guru

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: